Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance

An agency focused on community, relationships, tailored coverage, and better service for you.

About Us

An Independent Insurance Agency in Erie, PA Offering Personal Insurance and Business Insurance


At The Hilling-Pfeffer Agency,  we trace our origins back to 1955. With our nearly 70 years in business, our independent insurance agency in Erie, PA has grown from a history teacher’s side business to a multi-office operation with a focus on serving the complete insurance needs of local residents and businesses. We put our clients first and negotiate with our network of top-rated Carriers to help them acquire the best coverage and pricing possible. If you are seeking affordable personal insurance, comprehensive business insurance, life and health insurance, or need help with investments and retirement solutions, we are ready to help. Contact us today to learn more about the extensive suite of insurance products we offer.

Personal Insurance

We provide personal insurance solutions that are tailored to suit the unique needs of our clients. By maintaining strong relationships with many top-rated insurance carriers, we can develop a customized insurance package to provide you with full protection. From standalone auto policies to package policies that will protect your home, jewelry, cars, and more, Hilling-Pfeffer is the independent insurance brokerage in Erie, PA that you can trust to provide you with the quality coverage you deserve. We offer a diverse array of affordable personal insurance solutions designed to protect you against common and rare risks and provide advice intended to help you purchase the right coverage and avoid using it. You can find out about our entire suite of personal insurance solutions, then contact us for a discussion with a member of our team who is licensed and ready to help you obtain competitive insurance quotes.

Business Insurance

Adequate insurance coverage can be the one thing that keeps your business financially sound in the event of a catastrophe. Whether it is a sudden fire at your store, a slip and fall lawsuit from a customer, or sever weather, we can help you obtain insurance to keep your company safe. We offer Business owner policies that provide packaged coverage solutions as well as standalone coverage such as commercial auto insurance, commercial property insurance, general liability coverage, and more. Hilling-Pfeffer is an independent brokerage in Erie, PA that has been serving businesses like yours since our inception in 1955. We offer affordable commercial coverage from America’s top insurance carriers that we craft to perfectly suit the needs and operations of your business. You can explore our website to learn more about our commercial offerings before contacting us for competitively priced business insurance quotes.

Life & Health Insurance

Whether you need help with individual life and health insurance for yourself or a family member or if you want to set up commercial life and health coverage for your employees, Hilling-Pfeffer is here to help. For individuals and families, we have solutions including affordable term life insurance, robust whole life insurance, disability insurance, final expense insurance, and more. Our business life and health insurance solutions include key-man policies designed to ensure business continuity, group healthcare plans, group life insurance plans, and more. Our team of licensed life and health insurance brokers is here to make quoting and buying the coverage you or your business needs as simple as possible. We welcome the chance to provide you with advice and quotes that solve your life and health insurance challenges.

Financial & Investment

As our Erie, PA insurance brokerage has grown, we have sought to expand our suite of offerings to serve ever more client needs. Our expansion efforts have led to Hilling-Pfeffer becoming a source for financial and investment services and solutions. When you come to us to help with your Property and Casualty insurance needs, you can also work with our in-house licensed investment advisor to gain helpful advice and purchase financial tools sold through a top broker-dealer. Being able to handle as much of your insurance and financial needs as possible has allowed Hilling-Pfeffer to become a one-stop shop for many members of our growing customer base. While there is no obligation for our personal and commercial insurance clients to also utilize us for investment services, we suggest learning more about how we can help. You can read more about the financial solutions you can access through Hilling-Pfeffer here, and we welcome the chance to tell you more during a call or in person meeting soon.
Don’t just take our word for it

See What Our Clients Are Saying