We've been proudly serving the families and businesses of Pennsylvania, New York, Ohio and North Carolina since 1955.

Need an insurance quote? We are here to help.

Request a Quote

Auto

Basic Personal auto insurance is mandated by most U.S. states, and laws vary. Auto insurance coverages are priced individually to let you customize coverage amounts to suit your exact needs and budget.

Learn More

Home

Our first priority is to help you protect your family and your hard-earned assets by providing insurance protection that is tailored to meet your individual needs.

Learn More

Business

Whether you are a service company, professional, retailer or just about any type of business, we can tailor a program to match your business needs.

Learn More

Life & Health

Life and health insurance from Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance Agency can help you secure your family’s financial future by providing a variety of policies that suit you and your family.

Learn More

WHAT PEOPLE SAY

Kathy, Erie

Friendly nice staff....they were able to help me with everything I needed in less than an hour...

Frederick, Erie

Highly responsive, excellent explanation of benefits/coverage and provided me with instant upgrades for my photography business. We use Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance for our home, auto and business liability insurance needs.

Michael, Erie

The best insurance company in Erie. Alan Hilling goes above and beyond to take care of his clients. I have been a customer with this agency for 20 years.